A high school seniors 14foot banner proclaiming bong hits 4 jesus gave the supreme court a provocative prop for a lively argument monday about the extent of schools control over. No protection for bong hits 4 jesus lowering the bar. Mar 19, 2007 at a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking. Writing 4 the majority of 5, chief justice roberts joined by kennedy, alito, scalia, and, surprisingly. Mar 18, 2007 freespeech case divides bush and religious right. Supreme court ruled against an alaska high school student suspended in 2002 for unfurling a 14foot. Washington cnn the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. One of the most hotlydiscussed cases of this supreme court term was morse v. Frederick, in what legal experts say could be the most significant case on student free speech since the days of vietnam war protests.
The supreme courts bong hits 4 jesus first amendment decision. Supreme court allows foul language trademarks in fword case. Bong hits 4 jesus and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. A perfect constitutional storm in alaskas capital, in which he discusses morse v. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. Frederick, argued at the supreme court a few days ago, makes for some interesting reading. Bong hits 4 jesus goes to the supreme court by tom kizzia in the anchorage daily news is a good feature on the case, with additional information about frederick and his difficulties since the banner incident. It is the first supreme court case to do so directly since the court upheld the right of students to wear black. The first amendment takes a hit unprotected, and granting summary judgment against him. Jun 25, 2007 the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. Ken starr arguing that the principal had the right to suppress the speech focuses the beginning of his argument, predictably, with the usual drug czar type language. It held that fredericks speech was protected, because it did not fall into any of three kinds of. Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for ten days. Supreme court rules against student in bong hits 4 jesus.
District court lowest level of federal courts, where federal cases begin and trials are held. Jul 28, 2007 the us supreme courts recent opinion in morse v. June 25, 2007 a divided supreme court ruled monday that schools can punish a student without violating his. The supreme court heard arguments monday in the case of joseph frederick, the alaska high school student who was suspended for displaying a bong hits 4 jesus banner. The bbc reports on the supreme court ruling that a school in alaska did not violate joseph fredericks right to free speech when it suspended him for displaying a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus. Bong hits 4 jesus as a cautionary tale of two cities by. Court to decide bong hits 4 jesus banner case reuters.
Professor james foster talks about his book, bong hits 4 jesus, in which he discusses morse v. Certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit no. Supreme court uses bong hits 4 jesus case to limit. Sep 16, 20 bong hits 4 jesus banner on display at the newseum in washington, d. On june 25, 2007, the supreme court decided morse v. Former whitewater special counsel kenneth starr petitioned the u. The supreme court monday debated the case of a high school principal who suspended a student over a bong hits 4 jesus, banner displayed at a schoolsponsored event. Frederick, bringing the case better known as bong hits 4 jesus into widespread public attention. Jun 28, 2007 the us supreme court moved monday to tighten limits on free speech for high school students, ruling that an alaska high school could constitutionally punish a student who held up a 14footlong banner reading bong hits 4 jesus during a schoolrelated event. June 25, 2007 background joseph frederick, a senior at juneau douglas high school, held up a banner saying. Mar 05, 2011 washington cnn the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. Freespeech case divides bush and religious right the new. June 25, 2007 background joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school, held up a banner saying. Mar 19, 2007 the supreme court monday debated the case of a high school principal who suspended a student over a bong hits 4 jesus, banner displayed at a schoolsponsored event.
Early today the us supreme court overturned a 9th circuit decision in the case of morse v. Argued march 19, 2007decided june 25, 2007 at a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, petitioner morse, the high school principal, saw students unfurl a banner stating bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal drug use. Student press law center on the appeals court decision. Mar 19, 2007 justices hear bong hits freespeech case. Frederick, the majority acknowledged that the constitution affords lesser protections to certain types of student speech at school or at schoolsupervised events. Justice souter remarked that bong hits 4 jesus sounds like just a kids. The supreme court said on friday it would decide whether a high school principal violated a students freespeech rights by suspending him for unfurling a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus. Joseph fredericks unfurling of his bong hits 4 jesus banner was the subject of one of the supreme courts most highprofile cases. Frederick that there is no first amendment protection for a student who unfurled a banner supporting bong hits 4 jesus across the street from his school. I also draw important lessons from the justices differing views and suggest what they portend more generally for. Freespeech case divides bush and religious right the. The precipitious slide in supreme court protection for free speech in high school since tinker in the 1960s is only part of the story.
Frederick, the 2007 supreme court case conventionally known as bong hits 4 jesus. It held that fredericks speech was protected, because it. Student loses bong hits free speech case, 2007 newseumed. Justices to hear landmark freespeech case by robert barnes in the washington post. Penny starr a large bong hits 4 jesus banner, which led to a 2007 supreme court decision that said such language was not protected free speech under the first amendment when displayed at a public school event, is now on prominent display at the newseum in washington, d. The us supreme court moved monday to tighten limits on free speech for high school students, ruling that an alaska high school could constitutionally punish a student who held up a 14footlong banner reading bong hits 4 jesus during a schoolrelated event. Supreme court rules against bong hits 4 jesus student. To the right of the sign describing the bong hits 4 jesus banner is a sign that reads, student rights.
The socalled bong hits for jesus case previously made headlines not only for its unusual. Mar 19, 2007 a high school seniors 14foot banner proclaiming bong hits 4 jesus gave the supreme court a provocative prop for a lively argument monday about the extent of schools control over. Bong hits 4 jesus banner was free speech case overview archived bong hits banner gives supreme court chance to clear the air on student speech certiorari candidate archived bong hits 4 jesus toke three the washington post opinion, emil steiner. Frederick the bong hits case, and criticizes the supreme court for depreciating and diluting important first amendment values. The supreme court followed a course it took in 2017 when it struck down a similar law forbidding the registration of disparaging trademarks in a. In the present case, the majority acknowledged that the constitution affords lesser protections to certain types of student speech at school or schoolsupervised events. In my last column, i discussed the decision by the u. Aug 29, 2006 former whitewater special counsel kenneth starr petitioned the u. There, the ninth circuit held that a public high school student had a clearlyestablished first amendment right to display a bong hits 4 jesus banner at a privatelysponsored event that took place on a public street. Tomorrow the us supreme court will hear arguments in what will inevitably be known to future generations of law students as the bong hits 4 jesus case technically entitled morse v. As hard as it is to believe, the bush administration is at odds with one of its biggest supporters the religious right in the supreme court battle over bong hits 4 jesus. It found that frederick message was, by his own admission, not political, as was the case in tinker.
Mar 19, 2007 morse believed his bong hits 4 jesus banner was a prodrug message that schools should not tolerate. Finding that the message frederick displayed was by his own admission not political in nature, as was the case in tinker, the court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus. At a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, petitioner morse, the high school principal, saw students unfurl a banner stating bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal drug use. Oct 15, 2010 frederick, the 2007 supreme court case conventionally known as bong hits 4 jesus. A united conservative majority of the supreme court ruled today in morse v. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be.
Dec 01, 2006 the supreme court said on friday it would decide whether a high school principal violated a students freespeech rights by suspending him for unfurling a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus. Juneau, alaska several students unfurled a banner during relay that read, bong hits 4 jesus court decided school district was within its rights to discipline the students since they were at a school event and the bannerpromoted drug usage and officials could not be sued for monetary damages for carrying out their legal responsibilities. Former supreme court justice john paul stevens talked about students. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. May 12, 2008 frederick the bong hits case, and criticizes the supreme court for depreciating and diluting important first amendment values. Supreme court, where the nationally watched bong hits 4 jesus case will test the limits of free speech in public schools. The supreme courts bong hits 4 jesus first amendment. Consistent with established school policy prohibiting such messages at school events, morse directed the students to take down the banner. Supreme court ruled against an alaska high school student suspended in 2002 for unfurling a 14foot banner bearing the words bong hits 4 jesus during a. In this case, joseph frederick was a student at a public high school in juneau, alaska, and, on january 24, 2002, the olympic torch was due to pass in continue reading us supreme court. Supreme court to take up alaskas bong hits 4 jesus case, a dispute involving a high school student, a banner and a. The case centered around a student who decided to present a banner with the phrase bong hits 4 jesus at a school event. Analyzing the case under tinker, the lower courts had found no. The precipitous slide in supreme court protection for free speech in high school since tinker in the 1960s is only part of the story.
Student loses bong hits 4 jesus case june 25, 2007 10. Court of appeals for the ninth circuit in frederick v. Jun 25, 2007 washington cnn the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. Writing 4 the majority of 5, chief justice roberts joined by kennedy, alito, scalia, and, surprisingly, thomas wrote that the ninth circuit had been wrong to. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus case nbc news. Dec 27, 2006 washington cnn the supreme court entered into a freespeech dispute friday involving a high school student suspended over a bong hits 4 jesus banner. Frederick, better known as the bong hits 4 jesus case. Frederick sued morse, and that case now is before the court. For a summary of the facts, see my earlier comments on the case here. While watching the olympic torch being carried in juneau in 2002, 18 year old joseph frederick held up a large sign which said bong hits 4. Frederick, the supreme court case that addressed free speech in an american high school. A case in which the court found an alaska public school principal had the right to suspend a student for holding up a bong hits 4 jesus banner at a schoolsponsored event. The supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights.
I also draw important lessons from the justices differing views and suggest what they portend more generally for the likely direction of the current united states supreme court. Latest news bong hits 4 jesus goes to the supreme court. Bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal drug use. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus case fox news. The justices accepted an appeal from a school board in juneau, alaska, after a federal appeals court allowed a lawsuit by the family of joseph frederick to proceed. Jun 25, 2007 student loses bong hits 4 jesus case june 25, 2007 10. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus politics nbc news. The case arose when high school principal deborah morse confiscated a banner bearing that slogan from senior joseph frederick. Jun 25, 2007 early today the us supreme court overturned a 9th circuit decision in the case of morse v. The original bong hits for jesus banner that led to a supreme court decision on student speech now hangs in the newseum institute in washington, dc. Frederick brings to the forefront how far a public school may properly go in restricting student speech.
620 1204 466 1189 1189 773 943 390 1206 299 1007 470 1235 914 1038 1572 1165 1392 1403 832 396 429 1295 4 1108 1234 128 810 850 1515 1341 2 126 722 1500 495 1217 1535 984 1314 642 392 16 354 945 328 482 256