Crimes as well as the mode of punishment correlate to the culture and form of civilization from which they emerge1. South africa has a population of approximately 53 million people. Apr 17, 2010 south africa is currently number one on in the world for murder, rape and all crime and therefore earned the name crime capital of the world. They are the national party south africa, 10 the african christian democratic party, 11 african covenant 12, the african transformation movement atm 14 and the national conservative party of south africa. The death penalty debate by hon justice anthony bahati, chairman, tanzania law reform commission the death penalty has been a mode of punishment since time immemorial.
The death penalty debate south african history archive. Africa must move away from the death penalty amnesty. In 1977 when amnesty international started campaigning and advocating for the worldwide abolition of the death penalty no country in subsaharan africa had abolished the death penalty for all crimes. The current rhodes park murder and rape case would be an example. Compared to the rest of the world, africa has one of the lowest execution rates per capita. Tropical medicine and international health volume 4 no 6 pp 433441 june i999 k. End the death penalty after 10year execution hiatus. Hypothesized that there would be high popular support in south africa for the death penalty. The 36 pages study identifies the triggers leading to the abolition of the death penalty in africa. Pdf attitude to the death penalty in south africawith some.
If thought patterns about the death penalty in south africa are simplistic and simple. Jun 07, 1995 in its first major decision, south africa s recently created supreme court abolished the death penalty today, ending a decadesold practice of executing criminals convicted of serious crimes that. Sandra smith the last woman to be hanged in south africa. Funny game south africa 2010 world cup, you have to choose your country to face and move to eighths, quarters and semi final, if youre good you get to the final and win the world cup. The death penalty in south africa journal of the american. Capital punishment in south africa goes back at least to the seventeenth century, with the arrival of the dutch east indies company. In its first major decision, south africas recently created supreme court abolished the death penalty today, ending a decadesold practice of executing criminals convicted of. A comparative constitutional analysis andrew novak 1. The counties that use the death penalty the most have some of the highest reversal. The economic argument is usually a lastditch effort to appeal to rationalism, and it is not a very strong one for supporters of the death penalty since most information about the cost of the death penalty in comparison to other penalties show the death penalty as being much more costly. Since 5 years before the end of apartheid in south africa 1989, our criminal justice system has lacked the facility of the death penalty, as well as corperal punishment by the police since 1994. Introduction the mandatory death penalty for the crime of murder is in rapid retreat worldwide.
According to samantha spooner in african countries and the death penalty. Africa wu po jui low bo yang zhou wen tao gao yiming du han yuan goh guan xiong. The pace of abolition in subsaharan africa has been steady and promising. During apartheid, all positions as judges and prosecutors and all top positions in the police were occupied by whites, while it generally the blacks that regarded themselves as victims of the legal system. The standard method for carrying out executions was hanging, sometimes of. Amnesty international, included in this network, has argued against the death penalty in. Since 2007, the general assembly has also been calling for a global moratorium on the death penalty. A big portion of that are children that were raped to death.
Since 1992 we have been compiling death notices from public sources, such as the government gazette prior to 2008. A bad relationship they want to, but just cant, give up, studies show that the last official execution happened in 2003 1. Apr 24, 2015 as of 2014, 98 countries in the world, including south africa, had abolished the death penalty by law. Due to the fact that the death penalty no longer exists in south africa, the crime rate has increased dramatically. The death penalty between 1958 and 1989 in south africa 181 5.
Debate about the death penalty is firmly back on the table. Pdf attitude to the death penalty in south africawith. It was found that more than 3 in 4 young south africans think the death penalty should be reinstated as the highest form of punishment for criminals, spokesperson shirley wakefield said. Saha south african history archive youth on death row. Africa must move away from the death penalty the mail. Dec 01, 2016 last week, the report capital punishment in south africa, by the institute of race relations irr, dealt with that question. Foundation for human rights initiative, the international federation of action by christians for the abolition of torture, the international federation for human rights, and penal reform international, all members of the world coalition against the death penalty are pleased to participate in the 53rd ordinary session of the african commission on human and peoples rights, and would like to. Some psychiatric and psychological elements barend van niekerk it is with more than my usual measure of diffidence or stage fright that i rise to speak in this august assembly of lawyers, of psychiatrists, of rare hermaphroditic specimens of both vocations, of law professors although i. Death penalty in south africa has a long and unfortunate history. Linda geldenhuys, israel this is the 21st century and we must stop these cruel, inhuman and barbaric acts at once. Sessions and john gibbons joined illinois death penalty.
Without going so far as to abolish the death penalty, the american. Yet, the remaining retentionist states are reported to have carried out more than 600 executions over the course of 2011 alone. In africa, more than 80% of countries have abolished the death penalty in law or in practice, with only 10 countries executing within the past decade. The south african institute of race relations sairr this week published a study in which it asks whether there is a case for south africa to reintroduce the death penalty. Africa is seen as one of the death penalty regions in the world, as most african. Turrell bases his absorbing narrative on a thorough investigation of government statistics, court testimony, and. South africans are calling for the death penalty to be. South african death records online death person id. Introduction the death penalty is an extremely complex subject in many nations around the world.
The majority of young south africans want the death penalty to be reinstated, consumer insights company pondering panda said on friday. Why south africa should not reinstate death penalty the. As of 20, 30% of the population is under 15 years old, and only 9% is over 60. Since at present 58 countries, including the usa, which is considered to be the lighthouse of the western economic and human development, still retain it. South africa had one of the highest execution rates globally. Robert turrell presents a novel approach to the study of capital punishment in 20thcentury south africa. South africas supreme court abolishes death penalty the. I think that botswana is far more ahead of south africa good on them for protecting the innocent.
Deaths ratdmillion mf rate ratio 04 108 74 108 75 216 75 0. The ideal situation is that the death penalty should be abolished, or at best, the list of capital offences should be maintained at three or reduced even further. There were many campaigns against the death penalty and against detention without trial, both inside south africa and internationally. On 20 july the inkatha freedom party ifp stated that the time had come to discuss the possibility of reinstating the death penalty in south africa, and on the 8th of august the national freedom party called for the restoration of the death penalty in south africa after the death of khensani maseko, in a call similar to that of the ifp weeks before. African commission on human and peoples rights african commission established a. Two countries, south africa and the united states, travelled interesting and divergent. Foes of death penalty making gradual gains in africa the. Apr 25, 2017 tuberculosis, influenza, pneumonia, hiv, cerebrovascular disease, diabetes, and intestinal infectious diseases are all among the highest causes of death in south africa. Edmary mpagi, who spent 18 years on ugandas death row before being acquitted of crime, is part of growing movement to eliminate death penalty in. The death penalty in africa international federation for. In total, 140 countries have abolished it in practice.
The fact of the matter is that they leave such a wide latitude for differences of. For a thumbnail conspectus, see the judgment of chaskalson p. South africa is currently number one on in the world for murder, rape and all crime and therefore earned the name crime capital of the world. Every time a remarkable crime occurs remarkable either because of the fame of the victim or the extraordinary brutality of the act there are people calling for a debate on the restoration of the death penalty in south africa. White mercy focuses on official acts of mercy rather than on miscarriages of justice.
Determining cause of death in south africas rural northeast table i age and sex pattern of mortality, agincourt 199295 age male female total group no. Life or death the death penalty in the united states and. In 20, of the 54 member states of the african union, only 19 still hand out death penalties and, of those, only 5 conducted executions, one of which has since ceased the practice. The sa constitutional court abolishes the death penalty. Until the use of the death penalty was suspended in february 1990, south africa had one of the highest rates of judicial executions in the world.
The world day against the death penalty was introduced in 2003 by the world coalition against the death penalty, an international network comprised of ngos, bar associations, local governments and unions. Towards the abolition of the death penalty in by lilian. I fully appreciate and understand peoples need to bring back the death penalty. South africa have been shocked by the savage rape, disembowelment and murder, south africans basic human right the right to life is taken from. As of 2014, 98 countries in the world, including south africa, had abolished the death penalty by law. In april 1989 amnesty international issued an 11page external document dscribing the general use of. End the death penalty after 10year execution hiatus 22 july 2015, 00. Nov 23, 2016 the south african institute of race relations sairr this week published a study in which it asks whether there is a case for south africa to reintroduce the death penalty.
However, many south africans called for the death penalty to be reinstated after a surge in violent crimes and murders in the country. South africans calling for the death penalty home facebook. Abolition of the mandatory death penalty in africa. By the 1980s the number of people on death row increased dramatically. And the antideath penalty movement in africa, despite au support, has never been as strong as elsewhere in the world. Sandra smith was a 24 year at the time of execution old coloured woman official south african designation during the apartheid era who was married to a trawler man called philip and had two small children. Arguments on whether it is allowable under many nations laws have been occurring for some time now. Triggers for the abolition of the death penalty in africa.
Crime in south africa is an issue that the south african government is failing to address. Saha south african history archive the death penalty. The doctrine of extenuating circumstances passed into swazi criminal law via the criminal law and procedure amendment act of 1959, modelled on the south african provision. Solomon ngobeni was the last person to be officially executed in south africa in november 1989. The arguments for and against have not changed much over the years. Since 1994, use of the death penalty worldwide has sharply declined, going from 37 countries carrying out executions that year to 22 in 20.
The south has carried out 82% of the executions, the northeast, less. South african death records online death person id number. It looked into the pros and cons of reinstating capital punishment. Last week, the report capital punishment in south africa, by the institute of race relations irr, dealt with that question. Of 54 au states 38 retain the death penalty, albeit many dont use it. Aug 29, 2014 since 1994, use of the death penalty worldwide has sharply declined, going from 37 countries carrying out executions that year to 22 in 20.
Recently, a south african citizen, muziwokuthula muzi madondo, 33, was arrested in texas on 28 march 2011 in connection with four murders. Bring back death penalty south africa home facebook. Apr 24, 2017 africa must move away from the death penalty. Amnesty international, included in this network, has argued against the death penalty in all cases, without exception. At face value it is the scariest conviction any person could face, and as such one may believe it to be a good deterrent. Sandra smith was a 24 year at the time of execution old coloured woman official south african designation during the apartheid era who was married to. A survey conducted in 2015 by the south african research group pondering panda found that over 34 of young south africans wanted the death penalty back. Mohamed and another v president of the republic of south africa and others society for the abolition of the death penalty in south africa and another intervening 2001 3 sa 893 cc 2001 3 sa p893 citation 2001 3 sa 893 cc case no cct 1701 court constitutional court judge chaskalson p, ackermann j, goldstone j, kriegler j, madala j. Capital punishment, also known as death penalty, is a government sanctioned practice whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime. Turrell bases his absorbing narrative on a thorough investigation of government statistics, court testimony, and judges reports. States with the death penalty pay millions more in trial and imprisonment of death row inmates in contrast to trials where the death penalty is not optional. Random cluster samples of 100 ss each favoring the death penalty were johannesburg 56%, london 60%. Capital punishment in south africa was abolished on 6 june 1995 by the ruling of the constitutional court in the case of s v makwanyane, following a fiveyear and fourmonth moratorium since february 1990. Should the death penalty be brought back in south africa.
The irr has released a report on whether south africa should reintroduce the death penalty the report comes against a context of rising levels of serious and violent crime, often characterised by extraordinary cruelty and violence on the part of perpetrators. Nevertheless, those anxious years on death row were devastating. More then three thousand farmers have been murdered since 1994 and nearly more then 50 south africans are murdered per day. When south africa moved towards a democracy they were released from prison. Over 300,000 south africans have signed a petition calling for the death penalty to be reinstated, in the wake of several high profile murders and acts of violence against women in the country. The death penalty in africa recently there has been talk about rather africa should drop the death penalty or not. There are a number of parties in south africa that currently support the return of the death penalty. Advocating for the punishment of criminals living in south africa through the death penalty system. The death penalty in the interamerican human rights system. This trend across the african continent is less linear.
921 678 374 1328 459 966 1168 596 705 394 1095 13 344 821 1036 435 639 383 375 83 330 570 1073 116 1209 931 786 675 65 989 1114 28 59 189 1243 104 82